
Senior Affair may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
Serta and Beautyrest are two of the best known mattress names in America, and both are sold in most furniture stores. If you are replacing a mattress after 60, the right choice depends less on the logo and more on how you sleep, how easily you get in and out of bed, and whether aches wake you at night.
The short version
- Choose Serta if you want a softer, cushioned feel, sleep on your side, or want a wide range of prices. The Perfect Sleeper line is the familiar all-rounder; iComfort is the foam-forward line for pressure relief.
- Choose Beautyrest if you want a more supportive, springy feel, share the bed and are bothered by a partner’s movement, or prefer a firmer edge to sit on. Beautyrest is built around individually pocketed coils.
What matters most for older sleepers
Pressure relief for hips and shoulders
Side sleepers with arthritis usually do better on a medium or medium-soft surface that lets the shoulder and hip sink slightly. Foam-heavy models tend to do this well.
Support for the lower back
Back and stomach sleepers generally need a medium-firm surface that keeps the spine level. Pocketed-coil designs are strong here.
Edge support and bed height
A firm edge makes it easier to sit, put on shoes and stand up. Check the total height of mattress plus base: your feet should rest flat on the floor when you sit on the side.
Sleeping cool
Coil and hybrid mattresses let more air move through than all-foam models. If you sleep warm, lean toward a hybrid in either brand.
Adjustable bases
Both brands sell models that work with adjustable bases. Raising the head can ease reflux and snoring, and raising the legs can reduce swelling. Confirm compatibility for the exact model before you buy.
Before you buy
- Read the trial period and return terms, including any pickup fee.
- Ask whether delivery includes setup and removal of the old mattress.
- Check the warranty length and what counts as a defect.
- If you have chronic back or joint pain, ask your doctor or physical therapist what firmness they recommend.
Both brands run their largest sales around holiday weekends and Black Friday. Compare current pricing at Serta and Beautyrest before you decide.
Get guides like this in your inbox
Medicare changes, money tips, health guides and deals for adults 55+. Free, from Senior Affair Magazine.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.

